Buchholz Advances in a Muddy Win Against Nease
There was nothing pretty about Friday night at Citizens Field.
The rain kept falling, but Buchholz plowed through the mud to overcome a 12-point fourth-quarter deficit to defeat St. Augustine Nease 32-31 and punch its ticket to the Class 5A-Region 1 finals.
“I don’t know if this is a good tradition or not that we built — winning like this, but a win’s a win, and it’s a lot of fun,” Buchholz coach Mark Whittemore said. “It kind of takes some hairs off your head.
“On a night like this, it’s amazing that there was a turnover apiece. That’s impressive football in conditions like this.”
Buchholz (11-1) struggled to find its rhythm early, as Nease capitalized on its opening possession. Panthers quarterback Chase Phifer ran in a 2-yard touchdown to take a 7-0 lead with 8:32 remaining in the first quarter.
Penalties proved to be the Bobcats’ undoing early. The Bobcats leaned on the ground game, but a strong Nease defense forced back-to-back turnovers on downs.
The beginning of the second quarter seemed to be an upturn for Buchholz. Quarterback Andrew Whittemore connected with Avery Norris for a 50-yard pass to move the Bobcats into Nease territory.
Again, the Bobcats couldn’t capitalize. A personal foul on Buchholz gave the ball back to Nease. Buchholz was able to pull out a stop this time, forcing the Panthers to go three-and-out.
Nease (8-4) answered with the same ferocity. This time it was Buchholz with the three-and-out, as it was not able to get past its own 8-yard line and was forced to punt.
Nease extended its lead to 14-0 with 8:10 remaining in the second quarter after Phifer found the end zone on a passing touchdown.
Buchholz answered with 1:27 remaining in the first half when Whittemore punched in a 2-yard rushing touchdown to enter halftime trailing 14-6 after a missed extra point.
The Bobcats opened the second half with a spark. Running back Joshua Menefee broke free for an 80-yard rushing touchdown on the opening drive to cut the deficit to 14-12.
But Nease responded with a long run of its own before adding a field goal to make it 17-12 with nine minutes remaining in the third.
On the next drive, a Buchholz fumble gave Nease another opportunity. The Panthers took it and ran with it for a rushing touchdown to extend their lead to 24-12.
Whittemore answered again with another 2-yard rushing touchdown with 3:54 remaining in the third to bring the score to 24-19.
After a pass interference call against the Bobcats, Nease added another touchdown to take a 31-19 lead with 2:23 left in the third quarter.
Good fortune has happened twice for the Bobcats this season. Going into the fourth trailing 31-19, Buchholz needed a miracle, and it got one, just like the Jesuit game earlier this season.
A 3-yard rushing touchdown by Whittemore made the score 31-25.
Whittemore managed a 15-yard rushing touchdown on the Bobcats’ next possession, and the extra point by Timothy Ortiz put Buchholz up 32-31 with less than three minutes left in the game.
A late interception gave Buchholz the ball. With a minute left, the Bobcats took victory formation.
“The culture of winning is pretty noticeable, at this point,” Whittemore said. “I’m really, really pleased with the coaching staff, the program in general, and just these kids this year, 2026, just taking it to another level of tenacity, stick-to-itiveness and thoroughness in preparation. That’s a mental grind.”
Two seed Buchholz now travels to Jacksonville for next Friday’s region final against top seed Mandarin (11-1) at 6:30 p.m. The winner advances to the state semifinals.
“It’s gonna be a dogfight,” Whittemore said.
Category: Buchholz High School, High School Sports


